Chapter 7

Exercises

Skills Practice 7-1:  Breaking the Ice

Skill Objectives

  1. To obtain information from your fellow team members so you can work more effectively with them during the course of the project.
  2. To get acquainted with your fellow team members so that you can begin to develop positive working relationships with one another.

Procedure

  1. Form groups of four to six students each.  Ideally, each group will work together for an actual class project.  However, each group may be formed just for this exercise.
  2. Go around the group and provide the following information to one another: your name, year in school, major, and where you are from.
  3. Select one of the following ice-breaking activities to complete as a group.
    1. The Basic Q & A Exercise
    2. Step 1: State any one of the following questions to the team:

      > What’s your favorite movie of all time? Why?

      > What’s your favorite dessert? Why?

      > What’s your favorite thing to do for relaxation? Why?

      Step 2: Give your team members 10 minutes to obtain the answers to the chosen question from each other.

    3. The Four Statements Exercise
    4. Step 1:  Distribute one index card to each member of your team and ask them to write four statements about themselves on the card. Three of these statements should be false and one should be true. Be creative and make this fun!!

      Step 2: Bring the group back together and have each person read their statements and then ask the group which one they think is actually true.

    5. The “Let’s Do Lunch” Exercise
    6. Step 1: Tell your team that you would like to have an informal team meeting at a local restaurant.

      Step 2: Ask your team for suggestions as to where to have lunch. Select the restaurant by vote or consensus.

      Step 3: During the lunch, try not to talk about work issues. Rather, make “small talk” and try to get to know your team members as people.

    7. The Pictionary Challenge Exercise
    8. Note: Your instructor will need to bring the materials needed to conduct this exercise.

      Step 1: Select a team leader for the exercise.

      Step 2: Ask the team leader to take a marker or piece of chalk to the chalkboard (or dry erase board).

      Step 3: The team leader will be given a Pictionary card from the instructor and told which item or concept to focus on for the exercise.

      Step 4: When the instructor says, “Go,” the leader should attempt to draw the item or concept given to him/her without talking. The team should try to guess the correct answer.

      Step 5: Team performance is based on the number of seconds it takes a team to guess the answer. This exercise can be repeated, if time permits.

  4. Now brainstorm some ideas for a team name. Try to be creative.
  5. Decide on a team name based on the list you generated.

Discussion Questions

  1. What is the value of these simple activities? How do they help a group to develop itself?  What is the cost of not breaking the ice for the development and effectiveness of a team?
  2. Can these ice-breaking exercises be used with working people in real world organizations?  If so, do they need to be modified in some way?
  3. What are the practical implications of this exercise for you as a future manager of teams in real world organizations?>

Skills Practice 7-2: Developing Team Meeting Agendas

Skill Objective

To develop the skills needed to plan, facilitate, and evaluate a team meeting.

Procedure

  1. Form groups of 5 to 7 students.
  2. Read the following brief overview of tips for running effective team meetings in this chapter and below.

Brief Overview of Tips for Running Effective Team Meetings

  1. Assign one person to each of the following roles:
  2. Meeting Leader: This person is responsible for leading the team through the agenda.

    Facilitator: This person participates as a regular team member but also pays attention to the group process and ensures that the ground rules are being followed (e.g., making sure everyone participates and that the meeting starts and finishes on time).

    Scribe: This person takes notes regarding what was done in the meeting (e.g., issues discussed, decisions made).

  3. As a team, set specific ground rules that everyone on the team agrees to follow. These must be enforced consistently!
  4. Examples of Common Ground Rules

    • All meetings start and end on time.
    • All team members must come prepared.
    • One person talks at a time.
    • Everyone must participate.
    • Differences in opinion should be valued and respected.
  5. Criteria for evaluating a team process include:
    • Were the objectives of the meeting achieved?
    • Did the team stay on the agenda?
    • Were the ground rules followed?
    • Did all team members contribute to the team meeting?
    • Was there balanced participation across team members during the meeting?
    • Did all members of the team have a voice in any decisions that were made in the meeting?
    • Was the team open to hearing opposing viewpoints on an issue before making a decision?
    • Did the team summarize what each team member must do to meet their duties and responsibilities at the end of the meeting?
    • Did the team discuss when the next meeting will be and what each team member must come prepared with to the next meeting?
  6. Plan an agenda for a brief 15–25-minute meeting to complete a task or achieve an objective that the group selects (e.g., planning a social get-together, creating a study group for an upcoming exam, creating a timeline for a team project in a class, etc.). Make sure your agenda has the following elements:
    • Clear objectives
    • An itemized listing of the issues to be covered
    • A specific amount of time allocated for each agenda item

    Note:  You can download a meeting agenda worksheet that has been developed for this exercise from the web site for this book.

  7. Conduct the meeting according to your agenda.
  8. Evaluate your meeting process, and identify specific actions for improving future team meetings. 

Discussion Questions

  1. Why is it critical to plan meetings and to actively manage them?  What is the cost of not doing so?
  2. Why is the management of team meetings often much more challenging than it appears to be on the surface? 
  3. What do you think are the key things that need to be done in order to conduct an effective team meeting and how will you apply them once you are a manager in a real world organization?

Skill Practice 7.3: Movie Analysis: "Thirteen Days"

Objective

To develop skill in analyzing the nature and complexity of conflict in a major crisis and to understand the types of strategies used to handle this kind of situation.

Procedure

  1. Obtain a copy of the movie "Thirteen Days" starring Kevin Costner. It is available on DVD and can be rented or purchased from a local video store or retailer.
  2. Watch the movie (this can be done in class or at home on your own).
  3. Note: Download the worksheet that was developed for this exercise from the website for this book. This will help you to develop a list of relevant scenes in the movie for answering the discussion questions below.          

    As you watch the film, use the conflict model discussed in the chapter to help you to better understand the causes of the conflict and the strategies that are employed by both sides (the U.S. and the Soviet Union) to handle the situation. Document your notes from the film on your worksheet.

  4. Discuss the following questions as a class:
    1. What were the causes of the conflict that occurred in the movie?
    2. What kinds of strategies were used by the U.S. government to handle the situation? What type of conflict-handling style best describes the approach that was used by the U.S. government? To what extent was the U.S. government effective in resolving the conflict? Why?
    3. What kinds of strategies were used by the Soviet Union to handle the situation? What type of conflict-handling style best describes the approach that was used by the Soviet Union? To what extent was the Soviet Union effective in resolving the conflict? Why?
    4. What types of negotiating strategies are used by the U.S. and the Soviet Union throughout the film? Were they implemented effectively? Why or why not?
    5. What would you have done differently if you were a member of the U.S. government in the situation shown in the movie? What would you have done differently if you were a member of the Soviet Union in this situation?

Skills Practice 7.4: Applying the General Problem-Solving Process

Objective

To develop skill in applying the general problem-solving process to business problems.

Procedure

Note: Download the worksheet that was developed for this exercise from the website for this textbook. This will facilitate your working through this exercise.

  1. Identify a problem you are dealing with in your organization or school or something you have heard about in the news. Then, write a one-paragraph statement of the problem you select. Some example problems follow.
    1. The Harley Davidson motorcycle manufacturer is experiencing challenges in making its motorbikes more appealing to younger consumers and consumers abroad.
    2. The U.S. Armed Forces cannot recruit enough new people to meet its demand for labor.
    3. Eastman Kodak, the film and digital camera manufacturer, is experiencing challenges from a shrinking market for traditional camera film and intensified competition from other digital camera manufacturers such as Sony and Canon.
    4. Motorola, the wireless phone manufacturer, has been slow to develop new phones that incorporate emerging technologies such as integrated digital cameras into its phones.
    5. Ford Motor Company's Mercury division is experiencing problems with its identity and market positioning as luxury brands come out with lower-priced vehicles and less expensive brands come out with more luxurious models. The effect of this is that Mercury, which is supposed to be positioned between the more basic brands and luxury brands, is getting squeezed on both ends.
    6. A student organization has a low level of member involvement in the organization’s activities.
    7. A business school is struggling to identify what it needs to teach student in preparing them for the “real world.”
    8. Traditional retailers are losing market share to Internet-based retailers.
  2. Define the problem.
    1. Guidelines (see this chapter for more information):

    2. State the problem explicitly.
    3. Specify the standard(s) violated.
    4. Specify the problem in specific behavioral terms.
    5. Specify whose problem it is.
    6. Avoid stating the problem merely as an implied solution.
    7. Avoid stating the problem as a dilemma.
  3. Identify alternative solutions to the problem.
  4. Identify the criteria you will use to evaluate your alternative solutions and then evaluate your alternative solutions on the basis of those criteria.
  5. Select the best alternative solution to your problem.
  6. Identify the action steps you would take to implement your decision and to monitor and control the outcomes associated with the decision.
  7. Evaluate your problem solving process.

Discussion Questions

  1. What aspect(s) of the problem solving process did you handle effectively in this exercise? Why?
  2. What aspect(s) of the problem solving process did you not handle effectively in this exercise? Why?
  3. What are the barriers to the problem solving process that you encountered in this exercise? To what extent do these barriers also occur when solving problems in real world business organizations?
  4. Why is the problem solving process much more challenging to implement than it is to learn and understand in a textbook?
  5. What are the practical implications of this exercise for use as a future team leader or member?

Skills Practice 7.5: Affinity Technique

Objective

To create an agenda for a team meeting.

Procedure

  1. Download the accompanying worksheet.
  2. Complete the exercise by following the directions on the worksheet.

Critical Thinking Questions

  1. Describe how the affinity technique can help a team to make more effective decisions.
  2. What are the practical implications of this exercise for you as a team leader or team member?

Flashcards

Case Study #1: PDCA Examples: Implementing Change in Your Organizations

http://www.brighthubpm.com/methods-strategies/77327-pdca-examples-implementing-change-in-your-company/

  1. Describe how the PDCA was effectively implemented to solve problems in each of the cases.
  2. Sample Answer

    • Bathtub Installation Business. A team of workers at a bathtub installation business identifies a problem with the process for installing bathtubs taking too long. The team starts to track this and other factors related to installation time such as ordering time from the manufacturer, time customers take to make decisions about the bathtub they want, etc. By tracking data on a regular basis and using it to manage the installation process, the team was able to reduce the installation time.
    • Social Services Firm. A team was formed to address problems with excessive problem behaviors among residents. A goal was set to reduce problem behaviors by 25% and specific changes are being developed to achieve this goal based on ideas from team members.
    • Medical Clinic. A team was formed to reduce the amount of time between when an individual first calls to when he/she is assessed for treatment and only 71% show up for appointments. Due to changes made to scheduling and communications with clients, the length of time between initial phone call and assessment is reduced to five days and the show-up rate increased.
    • Public Schools. Students grades are evaluated and interventions are implemented to increase test scores based on the input of teachers, administrators, and board members.
  3. Based on the article, discuss the keys to successfully implementing PDCA to solve problems.
    • The change leader must be someone with all levels of an organization.
    • It is important to be able to demonstrate the negative impact of the
    • problem to organizational leaders.
    • Keep abreast of what other organizations are doing inside and outside the industry.
    • Conduct assessments of what customers want.
    • Institute changes using small teams.
  4. What are the practical takeaways from this case for you as future team leaders in organizations?
  5. Sample Answer

    • PDCA can be a highly effective tool for driving continuous improvement and solving problems in organizations. In order to be effective, it must be implemented by a team of individuals who are knowledgeable about the problem.
    • PDCA is a data-driven process so a team leader needs to ensure that appropriate metrics are used to measure the problem and that this data can be tracked and monitored in the future.
    • PDCA must be institutionalized into the culture and standard practices of a team so that it becomes a long-term solution to problems rather than just a short-term fix.

Case Study #2: NSW Department of Education & Communities

http://lrrpublic.cli.det.nsw.edu.au/lrrSecure/Sites/Web/13289/resources/documents/facilitators_guide/cstudnew.pdf

  1. Read through a couple of the cases and identify the key team challenges in each case.  Which facilitation strategies were used to address these challenges?  Were they effective? Why or why not?
  2. Sample Answer

    • Case Study #3: Lack of Trust Between Members. There is a lack of trust among some team members toward management as they perceive that management is not sincere about issues such as empowerment. This has created resentment from some team members and conflict, arguing over issues such as parking. The facilitator intervened and tried to get input from all members of the group on the parking issue by asking team member Chan what he thought about the issue. Some of the potential problems with this approach are that the parking issue is not the key challenge in this situation. Also, smiling in response to the team member’s comment about Chan being quiet may be viewed as being inappropriate or it could even alienate some members of the team from the facilitator.
    • Case Study #5: Conflict within a Group: A team is experiencing conflict as it goes through a culture change. The leader is trying to get the team to be more responsive to the marketplace but he is facing pushback from the team and they are withdrawing from their active involvement in the team. Four different approaches are offered as potential option s for handling the situation. Students may argue for different courses of action. Approach C has some advantages in that it focuses on asking questions to promote thinking among team members and to open up the communication process. Approach D attempts to validate everyone’s perspective but may not be as effective in moving the team forward in dealing with its issues. Approaches A and B are much more in-depth interpretations and they could come across as being too critical of the team.
  3. What are the practical takeaways from this case for you as future team leaders in organizations?
  4. Sample Answer

    • Team facilitation is a set of strategies for enhancing the effectiveness of a team’s process.  A good facilitator is a good detective in paying close attention to process issues in terms of verbal and non-verbal cues.
    • Team facilitators need to understand when it is important to ask questions to open up the communication process vs. being silent and letting the process unfold on its own.
    • Team facilitators need to earn the trust of the members of a team in order to be effective in their role.

Additional Resources

Articles on Teams

How to Hold a Team Meeting Without Wasting People’s Time
http://www.inc.com/veer-gidwaney/how-to-hold-a-weekly-team-meeting-without-wasting-people-s-time.html
How to Run Your Meetings Like Google and Apple
http://99u.com/articles/7220/how-to-run-your-meetings-like-apple-and-google
Seven Sins of Deadly Meetings
http://www.fastcompany.com/26726/seven-sins-deadly-meetings
Running Effective Meetings
https://www.mindtools.com/CommSkll/RunningMeetings.htm
Facilitating Meetings
http://www.seedsforchange.org.uk/facilitationmeeting
Role of a Facilitator
https://www.mindtools.com/pages/article/RoleofAFacilitator.htm
Organizing Team Decision Making
https://www.mindtools.com/pages/article/RoleofAFacilitator.htm
How to Make Good Group Decisions
http://www.yourofficecoach.com/topics/coworker_relationships/group_decision_making/how_to_make_good_group_decisions.aspx
How to Make Good Decisions as a Team
http://www.inc.com/les-mckeown/how-to-make-good-decisions-as-a-team.html
PDCA
http://asq.org/learn-about-quality/project-planning-tools/overview/pdca-cycle.html
Elements of the Group Decision Making Process
http://www.decision-making-solutions.com/group-decision-making-process.html
Nominal Group Technique
http://asq.org/learn-about-quality/idea-creation-tools/overview/nominal-group.html
Affinity Technique
http://asq.org/learn-about-quality/idea-creation-tools/overview/affinity.html

Videos on Teams

How to Run Team Meetings
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xW0CjH95K3Q
How to Keep Your Team Meetings on Task
http://www.inc.com/kristine-kern/kern-kristine-playbook-team-productivity.html
Start with Small Teams and Short Meetings
http://www.inc.com/aaron-patzer/stick-with-small-teams-and-short-meetings.html
Affinity Diagrams
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=he5WvisN6o0
The Truth about Brainstorming Meetings
http://www.fastcompany.com/3014542/creative-conversations/forget-what-your-mom-told-you-and-act-before-you-think
How to Do Group Brainstorming
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=urXGqyEUm4s

Books on Teams

Sibbet, D. (2010). Visual Meetings: How Graphics, Sticky Notes, and Idea Mapping Can Transform Group Productivity.  New York: Wiley.
Lencioni, P. (2004). Death by Meeting. A Leadership Fable… About Solving the Most Painful Problem in Business.  San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Friga, P.N. (2008). The McKinsey Engagement. A Powerful Toolkit for More Efficient and Effective Team Problem Solving.  New York:  McGraw-Hill.  Goal/QPC
Rees, F. (2001).  How to Lead Work Teams:  Facilitation Skills.  New York: Pfeiffer Publishers.
Kolb, J. (2011).  Small Group Facilitation: Improving Process and Performance in Groups and Teams.  Amherst: HRD Press.
Bens, I. (2000). Advanced Team Facilitation.  Salem:  Goal/QPC.

Additional Downloads